Here’s a bold prediction: the Philadelphia Phillies’ pursuit of Bo Bichette could be the domino that finally solves the Pittsburgh Pirates’ third base puzzle. But here’s where it gets controversial—while Phillies fans are dreaming of a supercharged lineup, Pirates supporters should be salivating at the opportunity this creates for their team. Let me explain.
Reports suggest the Phillies have scheduled a meeting with Bichette, a move that makes sense on paper for a win-now team desperate to close the gap. However, the real intrigue lies in what this means for their infield. With Trea Turner already manning shortstop, adding Bichette would create a logjam, forcing someone to shift—or worse, become expendable. And this is the part most people miss: that someone is likely Alec Bohm, whose name is already swirling in trade rumors as a potential casualty of this deal.
For the Pirates, this is a no-brainer. Their third base situation has been a revolving door of uncertainty for far too long. While their lineup boasts promising young talent, it’s the question marks that hold them back—especially at the hot corner. Bohm isn’t a superstar, but he’s a reliable stabilizer, exactly the kind of player the Pirates should be targeting. Consider this: in 2025, Bohm hit .287 with 11 home runs and a .741 OPS over 120 games. Meanwhile, Pittsburgh’s third basemen combined for a paltry .222 average, six home runs, and a .573 OPS. The upgrade is undeniable.
Here’s the kicker: Bohm and the Phillies recently avoided arbitration with a $10.2 million deal for 2026, but he’s set to hit free agency after 2027. If Philly views him as surplus to requirements post-Bichette, they’ll be motivated to move him. For the Pirates, this is a golden opportunity to land an everyday third baseman without breaking the bank. Yes, it’ll cost them—likely a prospect or two—but this is where their depth can shine, offering value without sacrificing their untouchable assets.
So, if the Phillies land Bichette, the Pirates’ path is clear: Don’t overthink it. Go get Bohm. Waiting for the market to ‘develop’ could mean missing out on a transformative move. But here’s the question for you: Is Bohm the missing piece Pittsburgh needs, or should they hold out for a bigger splash? Let’s hear your take in the comments—agree or disagree, this is one trade rumor worth debating.
